“That was my biggest fear,” Tina chimed in, “that Mick would become insanely jealous of seeing me with another man. That we’d both feel guilty afterwards, or become distrustful of each other. But we talked about it, a lot, before we even thought of actually trying something with another person.”
“There’s got to be a lot of trust involved, I would think,” mused Lonnie.
“Oh, yes,” Mick answered. “And we discussed our rules and boundaries. No playing with others apart from each other. No ‘taking one for the team,’ one of us having to fuck somebody we weren’t interested in just so the other could get with someone they liked, and so on.”
“We started slowly,” Tina continued. “We found a lovely woman at the swingers club who was there by herself, looking for a couple. I played with her only a little before letting Mick fuck her. It was nerve-wracking at first, but I found myself really enjoying it, watching them please each other. Although Mick still held back a bit. He made her cum, then came right back to me to finish. And that made it truly special.
“We agreed from then on that no matter what else we did, or who we did it with, that we’d always make sure to come together again afterwards and reconnect. It really strengthened our bond.”
“Speaking of reconnecting,” Mick broke in,” do you mind if I take my wife back now, Chuck?”
“Of course,” Chuck laughed. “Thank you for sharing her with me.”
Tina kissed Chuck one more time. “Thank you,” she said, “you were wonderful.”
Lonnie scooted over as Tina took her place by Mick’s side. Embracing her husband, she kissed him passionately.
“So, I’m still curious,” Lonnie said, “why go through all the effort of trying to pick the both of us up tonight when you could have just gone to the swingers club and met a couple you know would be willing? We could have said no and your night would have been ruined!”
Mick grinned. “True. But the swingers club got…old, after a while. And it’s not exactly our scene. Plus, the closest one is in Philly, about an hour away, and neither of us wanted to be in the city tonight. I’m sure it’s crazy over there right now after that game.”
“Also,” Tina added, “we enjoy the extra challenge of finding someone outside the ‘lifestyle’ to play with. It doesn’t always work out, but when it does, it just feels more…special, somehow.”
“Well it was pretty special for me too,” Chuck said.
“Same,” Lonnie chirped with a laugh. “I haven’t done anything even remotely close to this since my college days. And after several less than successful relationships, it was nice to just chuck all the bullshit and have a good old fashioned fuckfest.”
“Oh, no pun intended there, Chuck,” she finished, invoking laughter from the rest.
“Well, we’re both very glad to have given you such a memorable evening,” Mick said. “And it’s not over. Unless you want it to be, of course.”
Standing, he took Tina by the hand. “I’m taking my wife to our bedroom now. You’re both welcome to join us.”
Mick saw the look of surprise on their faces. “You can watch, if you’d like. Or, you know…whatever,” he winked.