Elizabeth listened to all of Amy’s advice very carefully, and then turned her attention back to the dick in her hand. Slowly, she leaned over and took me into her mouth.
I groaned loudly at the sight of this young girl taking her first cock, my cock, into her mouth. She had obviously been paying close attention to Amy’s input, as she nailed each piece of advice with near precision. She couldn’t fit all of my cock in her mouth, but she managed about half before gagging. Amy encouraged her to keep gagging herself, as it creates “spit lubricant”; as Amy called it. Since Elizabeth couldn’t get it all in her mouth, Amy also suggested she stroke the part that wouldn’t fit with her hand.
Elizabeth followed instruction wonderfully. Soon the whole front of her shirt was covered in slobber as she kept trying to fit more and more of my dick in her small mouth. Amy reached over and pulled Elizabeth’s shirt over her head, revealing her small breasts. Elizabeth’s nipples were small brown points centered on each of her budding mounds. Elizabeth seemed to hardly notice her disrobing as she worked my cock feverishly.
“Hey Ann! Your sister is going to be one hell of a cock-sucker,” Amy called back over her shoulder, confirming my earlier suspicion about Ann and Elizabeth being sisters.
“Must run in the family,” Ann replied back, and all the girls laughed.
“My jaw is starting to get sore,” Elizabeth complained after several minutes.
“Well he’s already cum twice,” Amy reasoned. “I think maybe it’s time we tried something else.”
Elizabeth took Amy’s cue and moved to the side. Amy slowly slid off her green one-piece. I looked down to see her reveal her beautifully small breasts. They were only slightly larger than Elizabeth’s and were capped with the same small, hard, brown nipples. Between her slender legs I could see a neatly trimmed patch of straight black pubic hair. As she turned around, I was treated to an amazing view of her small, inviting ass. Not being able to touch these girls was really beginning to really suck. Amy positioned herself over my lap.
“Don’t you want one of these?” Elizabeth asked, holding up a condom she had pulled from the bowl Lindsay had stocked.
Amy only shook her head “no” as I felt her reach between her legs to guide my cock into her tiny, waiting pussy.
She was tight. Really tight. She had to work herself up and down several times before she finally managed to fit my whole length inside her. Once she did, she paused only for a moment before slowly started riding me. She was so wet I could hear my cock sliding in and out of her. The heat from her pussy was amazing, and despite how tight she was – because she was so wet – she was able to fuck me with relative ease. She was moaning uncontrollably now, and I would have given anything to be able to grab her by that sexy ass and push her down as hard as I could on to my cock.
“Oh my God,” she kept saying. “I’m never fucking a boy again. Holy shit he feels amazing”
She was riding me with abandon now. Anytime she would slam down on my cock particularly hard, she would let out a sharp yelp and fuck me harder. I could see the other girls had paused their game and were turned around, watching now. Lindsay was smiling grandly.