We both sank to the floor and curled up with each other. There were no words for a long time. Finally, “Tim, about what you saw and heard in there…we need to talk.”
A week later I pull up to the giant house where the biggest Halloween party I’ve ever seen is taking place. My instructions were crystal clear and I was grateful that the pants of my Beetlejuice costume were baggy enough that it hid my erection from view. People in costume are dancing outside as speakers blast Bela Lugosi’s Dead. Skeletons, monsters, ghosts and goblins all writhing to the pulsing beat. I know that they are here but I don’t have a clue how they are dressed. Still with all the sexy witches, slutty vampires, and other women dressed in other types of hot goth girl attire I wasn’t too disappointed I hadn’t seen them yet. Everywhere you looked there were legs in fishnets, bodies in black lace or leather and more than enough cleavage on display. Even the more conservative costumes were worn by women at least a size too small to show off their figure. This was my favorite part of the holiday, even the good girls played bad tonight.
I just mixed in with the crowd and started dancing, trying to relax myself a bit for what I knew lay ahead. The idea was so hot I had already masturbated twice today thinking about it and still I was hard as a rock. Colleen had been nervous telling me about this as we laid on her bedroom floor. It had started after they had all met in college. They liked fucking each other but they wanted men too. So they had made a pact, if any of them found a good guy, she’d have to share him with the group. Colleen said it had been fun in college her two girlfriends and dick on command but afterwards when they had all split apart for their new lives, she thought it was over. She’d flown out on occasion to be with Jackie or Beth as that was a bond she never wanted to break, she thought the sharing was over with. She met me and I was surprised as she told me she was so serious about us, she was thinking about breaking it off with Jackie and Beth. Then their jobs both transferred them here and they wanted to pick back up where they left off in college. She got super serious, looked directly into my eyes, and asked if I would be okay fucking her two girlfriends.
Now I could play all cool and try telling you that the thought of having two more women was all I cared about, but I’ve always been in monogamous relationships. The lesbian display I had witnessed was hot, and I was already horny, so I hadn’t had time to feel cheated on. And I definitely didn’t want to cheat on Colleen. It was hard saying all that in the moment with her but I eventually got it all out. She had smiled at me with tears in her eyes. “It’s not cheating if we give each other permission. I have no more secrets and if you say no, I’ll go down and tell them I’m out for good. I love you Tim. But if you say it’s okay, you are going to have a really good time.”
I still felt the heat in that kiss after I said yes. I knew it was what she wanted and I admit I found Jackie and Beth both attractive. YOLO, right? So Colleen planned everything out for tonight. Great party, alcohol to loosen everything up, and sex with three gorgeous women.